| 2024 | | | | |
| Gabe Fraser | IF | Milwaukee Brewers | Arkansas |
| Chandler Murray | 1B | Milwaukee Brewers | Kansas State |
| 2020 | | | | |
| Tyler McDougal | RHP | Cincinnati Reds | Oregon |
| Charlie Saum | C | Milwaukee Brewers | Stanford |
| 2019 | | | | |
| Tony Castonguay | C | Cincinnati Reds | Kansas |
| Charlie Saum | C | Milwaukee Brewers Underclass | Stanford |
| Max Rajcic | RHP | Milwaukee Brewers | UCLA |
| Jon Jon Vaughns | RHP - 1B | Milwaukee Brewers | UCLA |
| Jauron Watts-Brown | RHP | Oakland A's | Long Beach State |
| 2018 | | | | |
| Ty Collins | RHP | Milwaukee Brewers Underclass | USD |
| Carter Rustad | RHP | Washington Nationals | USD |
| Jake Saum | LHP | Milwaukee Brewers | UCLA |
| Jon Jon Vaughns | RHP - 1B | Milwaukee Brewers Underclass | UCLA |
| 2017 | | | | |
| Emilio Rosas | IF | Milwaukee Brewers | USC |
| Carter Rustad | RHP | Washington Nationals Underclass | USD |
| 2016 | | | | |
| Kevin Abel | RHP | Milwaukee Brewers | Oregon State |
| Hunter Breault | RHP | Cincinnati Reds | Oregon |
| Emilio Rosas | IF | Washington Nationals Underclass | USC |
| 2015 | | | | |
| Kevin Abel | RHP | Milwaukee Brewers Underclass | UCLA |
| Jack Dashwood | LHP | Milwaukee Brewers | UCSB |
| Avery Tuck | OF | Milwaukee Brewers | San Diego State |
| Nate Walker | RHP | Milwaukee Brewers | USD |
| Ezele Wicks | OF | Milwaukee Brewers Underclass | Sonoma State |
| Jonathan Worley | RHP | Milwaukee Brewers | Stanford |
| 2014 | | | | |
| Kolby Allard | LHP | Milwaukee Brewers | UCLA |
| Chris Betts | C | Milwaukee Brewers | UCSB |
| Bailry Falter | LHP | Milwaukee Brewers | UCSB |
| Matt Hartman | RHP | Milwaukee Brewers | UofA |
| Kyle Molnar | RHP | Milwaukee Brewers | UCLA |
| 2013 | | | | |
| Chris Betts | C | Milwaukee Brewers | UCSB |
| Bailry Falter | LHP | Milwaukee Brewers | UCSB |
| Kyle Molnar | RHP | Milwaukee Brewers | UCLA |
