Western Athletic Conference
| Year | School | First Name | Last Name | HS | Position |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2024 | New Mexico State | Ian | Hoslett | San Dieguito Academy | RHP |
| 2022 | Seattle | Sebastian | Lopez | Coronado | IF |
| 2020 | New Mexico State | Porter | Pittman | Eastvale | OF |
| 2020 | UNLV | Ethan | O'neal | Liberty | RHP |
| 2019 | Northern Colorado | Shaydon | Kubo | Iolani | IF |
| 2017 | Dixie St | Drake | Benner | Sage Creek | OF |
| 2017 | Utah Valley | Brandon | Luna | Vista Murrieta | 1B |
| 2017 | Utah Valley | Blake | Zeleny | Brawley | LHP |
| 2016 | New Mexico State | Chance | Hroch | Vista Murrieta | RHP |
| 2016 | New Mexico State | Joey | Ortiz | Pacifica | IF |
| 2015 | New Mexico State | Jason | Bush | Cypress | C |
| 2015 | New Mexico State | Tristen | Carranza | Brawley | 1B |
| 2014 | Grand Canyon | Ian | Evans | Charter Oak | IF |